Frosty's Ice Cream and Reilly's Hardware

Call Directions

Frosty's Ice Cream and Reilly's Hardware Family owned Ice Cream Shop and Hardware Store in the heart of Cedarville, New Jersey.

Hardware store Hours
Mon. 8am to 5pm
Tues. 8am to 5 pm
Wed. 8am to 5pm
Thur. 8am to 5pm
Fri. 8am to 5pm
Sat. 8am to 5 pm
Sun. 8am to 2 pm

Drop something off or just share this post. Every little bit helps.
11/04/2026

Drop something off or just share this post. Every little bit helps.

10/30/2026

🎃🍦 HALLOWEEN TREATS ARE BACK AT FROSTY’S! 👻🍨

We’re excited to announce that Frosty’s Icecream is continuing our Halloween tradition again this year!

On Halloween 10/31 from 4 PM – 7 PM, anyone who stops by dressed in their Halloween costume will receive a FREE small ice cream! 🍦🎃

It’s our way of giving back to the wonderful community that continues to support us year after year!

Bring the kids, show off those costumes, and stop by for a sweet treat on us!

⏰ 4 PM – 7 PM
🍦 FREE Small Ice Cream for Anyone in Costume
🎃 While Supplies Last

From all of us at Frosty’s Icecream, thank you for another great year of support! We look forward to seeing everyone dressed up!

Happy Halloween! 🎃👻

10/27/2026
10/19/2026

Something wickedly wonderful is coming to Three Petals Farm.

Join us for the Witches Market on October 30 from 6:30–10 PM.

Spend the evening browsing local makers, unusual finds and seasonal offerings in a setting made for a little autumn magic.

Three Petals Farm
3109 Cedarville Road
Millville, New Jersey

Children under the age of 18 must be accompanied by an adult.

Feel free to wear your costume! Some of the vendors will be giving out candy.

Pre-registration is available for different experiences:

- past life regression session with Hypno-Witch Edith Hignutt (limit 50 people)

- make-your-own potion session (limit 20 people)

- flower crown making session (limit 20 people)

**pre-registration is available while supplies last.
Pre-registration can be done through Eventbrite:
https://www.eventbrite.com/e/1997620614031?aff=oddtdtcreator

10/12/2026

We are always willing to try it for you! 😂😂

Two new specials! Peanut Butter Crunch Berry Blast & Cookie Monster Sundae!
10/04/2026

Two new specials! Peanut Butter Crunch Berry Blast & Cookie Monster Sundae!

10/02/2026

🚨 Please take note of our change in hours. Frosty’s will now be closing at 8PM for the rest of the season. As always, our last day will be October 31! We look forward to serving you for the rest of the month! Thank you!

09/27/2026

🌧️🍦 Well…the weather wins again!

We were hoping Mother Nature would give us a break today, but unfortunately it looks like another day to keep the windows closed at Frosty’s Ice Cream.

We’ll be closed for today and keeping our fingers crossed for some better ice cream weather soon! ☀️🤞

Thank you all for continuing to support Frosty’s — we truly appreciate you! Stay dry, and we’ll see you as soon as the sunshine decides to come back! 🍦💙

Address

345 Main Street
Cedarville, NJ
08311

Opening Hours

Monday 12pm - 9pm
Tuesday 12pm - 9pm
Wednesday 12pm - 9pm
Thursday 12pm - 9pm
Friday 12pm - 9pm
Saturday 12pm - 9pm
Sunday 12pm - 9pm

Telephone

(856) 447-3030

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Frosty's Ice Cream and Reilly's Hardware posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Nearby hardware services